Two of my grandfather's books
Two of my grandfather's books
The black and white map may be one my grandfather carried with him at the front. The color map was in a book published later about touring the battlefields.
The black and white map may be one my grandfather carried with him at the front. The color map was in a book published later about touring the battlefields.
I’ve been examining my grandfather’s diary again, the little notebook where he jotted down where he was day-by-day once he got drafted and sent to the war. I’ve been puzzled by two periods of time – between Oct. 17 and Nov. 2, and between Sept. 20 and Oct. 6 -- where he writes almost nothing.
What happened during both of those two weeks periods?
Now I have a good idea about what happened and probably why he didn’t write down his movements. I didn’t even have to go to the library, research online or consult an expert: my grandfather left me two particularly useful books as well as his battered map, and they plot out in detail the two plus months leading up to armistice (Nov. 11) that his Yankee Division is most famous for, including exactly what was happening during those mystery weeks. The story is both awful and awe-inspiring at the same time.
In an earlier post, I referenced all of my grandfather’s night marches starting Aug. 31, arriving in woods and leaving the woods night after night until Sept. 11. That was all part of the movement of a huge number of American troops to get in place for something kind of momentous: the very first operation of the war conducted by a complete American army under independent control of the Americans. There were more than 550,000 Americans involved in this plan, in addition to the 110,000 French troops who they would fight alongside as part of this operation.
In the early morning hours of Sept. 12 the Americans began an attack, mostly aiming to destroy the barbed-wire that stretched six to eight miles deep in some areas, protecting the German positions. By the evening, the Americans were able to move forward into position, when new instructions arrived that apparently took them by surprise.
“But now orders were coming down for something utterly strange and new in character, something that smacked of the adventurous, -- a daring, impertinent dash right into the solar plexus of the Hun territory, without scouts, or information, or any idea of what might be encountered,” is how Captain Daniel W. Strickland, author of Connecticut Fights, one of my grandfather’s books, describes the plan. (The quoted accounts use “Hun,” a derogatory wartime term for Germans. I’ve kept it here as part of the original text, reflecting the language of the sources. Connecticut Fights is copyrighted 1930.)
The idea was to essentially squeeze the Germans, with the Americans and French pushing from the northwest and simultaneously from the southeast toward a town called Vigneulles, which, if successful, would essentially trap the Germans in between Vignuelles to the east and St. Mihiel to the west. On the ground, the guys didn’t have a clue if there were reinforcements coming behind them or if there would be any cover for them as they pushed forward. They didn’t know how many German troops were in the area or what to expect in terms of defense.
My grandfather was in the regiment starting from a town called Mouilly, northwest of Vignuelles. It was a nine kilometer walk through the night, smack through enemy territory, following an ancient road. “Down the long straight road they started, the gloom of night lighted only by the reflection from burning towns fired by the Hun as he retired, the silence broken only by the regular quick step of the battalions falling on the road. From the right and left came mysterious sounds as the enemy, skulking to the rear by cross roads and lanes, tried to keep himself hidden from the columns of unidentified infantry that were so nonchalantly parading into the interior of the salient,” Strickland writes.
He calls it “adventurous,” I call it bonkers. Can you imagine, walking down this road at night, surrounded by forest on both sides, and aware that dudes with guns are hidden from sight in the forest? But somehow they made it, with my grandfather’s Yankee Division the first to enter the town of Vignuelles, with basically no resistance from the enemy. My grandfather writes in his diary: “Reached our objective Vignuelles,” as if it’s nothing.  
This page references reaching Vignuelles and capturing the Romanians
This page references reaching Vignuelles and capturing the Romanians
Not much between Sept. 20 on the previous page and Oct. 6
Not much between Sept. 20 on the previous page and Oct. 6
The pink swath in the upper left is the Yankee Division (26th). If you study these maps for a while you start to understand how they work!
The pink swath in the upper left is the Yankee Division (26th). If you study these maps for a while you start to understand how they work!
And then apparently describing the next couple of days he adds: “Bosh prisoners and equipment. Advance for 12 hours. Saw about 10 towns burning. Bombed by aeroplanes.”
I think by “bosh” he means “boche,” which I’ve learned was a derogatory, slang French term for Germans that the American troops picked up. Sadly, the airplane bombing that he mentions may have been friendly fire, referenced in Strickland’s book, which occurred on the 14th and killed nine and wounded “many” others. My grandfather underlined the phrase “bombed one of the battalions” in the description of the incident in the book.
Those few days of fighting were very successful with the Allies capturing 16,000 prisoners, 443 cannons and 200 square miles of territory. Plus, important railway lines that had been held for a very long time by the Germans were freed for use by the Allies to move equipment.
Over the next few days American troops battle outwards to the north and east on many different fronts. My grandfather writes that he’s in and out of the woods again on Sept. 15 and 16, “under shellfire all times.” On Sept. 17 he records the momentous occasion of receiving mail from home.
The next day, he’s sent over the top on a raid and under machine gun barrage manages to take 15 Romanian prisoners.
I think there are some errors in Strickland’s book – he may have mixed up two raids that happened on the same day. But regardless, Strickland also mentions 16 Romanian prisoners being taken.
Sadly, my grandfather and others appear to be omitted, at least in this book, from the list of people who participated in the raid. In pencil in the book, my grandfather added his name and vaguely references other Ohio men wounded in the raid (I can’t make out the writing, can you? What comes after “Ohio men” and before “wounded in raid?”).
My grandfather wrote in his name as a participant in this raid.
My grandfather wrote in his name as a participant in this raid.
Now we reach the first big gap in my grandfather’s diary, between Sept. 20 and Oct. 6. According to the books I have, starting on Sept. 26, his division was involved in attacks in Riaville and Marcheville that sound pretty bad. The Americans have some successes but also some very heavy losses and some lost ground.
Morale takes a hit, in part because it became common knowledge that the plan for the divisions fighting in this sector was to basically keep the Germans busy so that they weren’t able to move up north, where the big final Argonne battle was about to begin. These guys felt like they were being sacrificed as a diversion.
Plus, they haven’t had a break for ages. On Sept. 27, the division commander sends a note to the commanding general requesting leave for my grandfather’s Yankee Division. “They have not had leaves since their organization,” he writes. But he’s denied. Instead, there’s a bunch of movement of troops over the next few days, with my grandfather walking at night through Ranzieres, St. Mihiel, Dugny and eventually arriving in Verdun on Oct. 9.
Why didn’t my grandfather take note of his daily movements over this period? My guess is a combination of not having a minute to put pencil to paper and possibly not having a clue where he was or even what day it was. The bombing, gassing, and constant movement were relentless. I don’t think he’d had any kind of break since he started walking on Aug. 31 – a little over a month earlier.
From Oct. 10 – 15 he does get a bit of a break, holed up in Verdun, where his division had the chance to clean up a bit.
But that’s it. On Oct. 15th, it all begins again when he’s sent to the front lines of Verdun, joining the big final battle of the war, Meuse-Argonne. Now comes the second two-week gap in his diary. He writes that he’s in the front lines on Oct. 17. There’s a word I can’t make out and then:
mach. guns, gas, barrage
Over the top 3 times in Argonne Woods
Took a bath in Meuse river.
The next entry is Nov. 2. 
Those missing two weeks sound even worse than the previous missing weeks. It is nonstop chaos, day and night, under constant shelling, with terrible weather and illness spreading rapidly. Lots of senior officers get killed and there’s lots of confusion and many stories of small groups of men separated from their divisions – or the only survivors left -- banding together, at times joining up with anyone else they can find.
During one two hour period during this time, 10,000 shells fell in the sector occupied by my grandfather’s 102nd Infantry, most of them falling on Cote 360 – a hotly contested hill. On one of the maps, my grandfather marks the hill with an X or a cross – maybe he was there. Some battalions that started in September with 1,000 men had fewer than 150 left at the front by early Oct. My grandfather’s division at this point had set the record for the longest stay in the front line of any division that had served in France.
My grandfather marked a cross or an X on Hill 360
My grandfather marked a cross or an X on Hill 360
Can you make out the first word, in front of "Mach. Guns"??
Can you make out the first word, in front of "Mach. Guns"??
Strickland’s book records the messages and letters sent amongst the higher ups that describe a pretty desperate situation.
“All men in sector in very weak and bad condition. It is absolutely impossible for these men to do any more offensive work in my estimation,” a man named Connelly, rank unidentified, wrote in a message delivered by runner on Oct. 28 to the CO of the 102nd Infantry, as reproduced by Strickland in Connecticut Fights.
“Absolutely impossible for these men to do more offensive work as they are physically all in. They are so dead tired it is almost impossible to wake them once they fall asleep,” Lt. Gambel, wrote in a message to the CO of the 104th Infantry at almost the same time.
“The N.C.O. in charge of companies all state they cannot hold their men under fire in their present nervous and exhausted condition,” the commanding officer of the 1st Battalion of the 102nd Infantry reported.
In very early November, a report was made by a Colonel acting under orders from the Inspector General about the condition of 51st Infantry Brigade, which included my grandfather’s unit. It was pretty grim. Most of the men were “shell shy,” mentally and physically exhausted, and “not in condition for even defensive operations.”
“The Division Surgeon showed me a letter from one of the psychiatrists of the 101st Sanitary Train in which he reported in very forceful terms the mental state of depression of a great many men coming under his observation,” the Colonel wrote. 
Just like the first missing two weeks in my grandfather’s diary, I suspect this second gap is for a similar reason: keeping a record in a notebook was probably the last thing he cared about. Even after it was over, he maybe had no idea where he’d been or even what day it was.
And now we come to the next chapter of my grandfather story. It’s the sad part that I’d never heard before stumbling on his diary and that I wonder if my dad even knew about. More on that soon in my next post…
A quick postscript about a correction in a previous post. When I first wrote about all the night walks from Aug. 31 through Sept. 11, I said my grandfather would have covered 85 miles. That’s wrong – it would have been more like 30 miles. Before writing this post I decided to plot all the towns my grandfather mentions on a map. That’s when I learned that there are lots of similar town names. I also noticed that Tronville is pretty far east of all this fighting – it seemed unlikely that was the starting point of those night walks. As I was reading the books my grandfather left I saw mention of a town called Tronville-en-Barrois. It’s southwest of the fighting and a more likely spot for my grandfather to have started walking. From that Tronville to Mouilly is more like 30 miles.
↑Back to Top